7 Best Rubber Riding Boots [Expert Top Picks’ Review]

Looking for the best rubber riding boots?

I know what a challenge this is because they are hard to find!

To save you the heavy lifting, and eye-blurring chore, I put together a round-up of the top picks.

Let’s take a look.

This post contains affiliate links. We earn a commission if you make a purchase at no extra cost to you.

Our Favorite Rubber Riding Boots at a Glance

• Horze Palermo Paddock Boots Women’s (WINNER) 
• Ovation Derby – Men’s Lined Rubber Riding Boot – Men’s (WINNER)
• Horze Bonn Rubber Paddock Boots – Budget Friendly
• HORZE Chester Tall Dress Boots – Flexible
• Muck Boots Derby Ankle Rubber Riding Boot – Most Comfortable

Don’t have time? Here is a quick comparison of our favorites!

Top 7 Rubber Riding Boots Reviews

Rubber riding boots are great because you are guaranteed that your feet will stay dry. They are perfect for barn work and riding on rainy days.

With that in mind, it is a good idea to have a pair, so let’s take a look at my favorites.

#1 Horze Palermo Paddock Boots Women’s (WINNER) 

These are fantastic women’s rubber riding boots. They are paddock boots, which I prefer for riding when they are made with rubber.

I find tall rubber riding boots, can end up tricky to get on and off. And they don’t fit as well as leather boots.

If you want boots for around the barn that will keep your feet dry, especially in winter or on rainy days, it is good to have a rubber pair. This will help keep your leather boots in good condition so they last longer.

Also, rubber riding boots are pretty budget-friendly compared to real leather. These HORZE boots are pull-on and have elastic gullets that help make them easy to slip on and off. 

Of course, being rubber they are waterproof. They have a sturdy sole with a decent grip and an appropriate heel for horse riding. These are both suitable as beginner boots and for those more experienced.

The toe is round, which riders with wide feet might find more comfortable. Let’s take a closer look at these boots.

Features & Attributes

• Elastic panels
• Made of durable rubber
• Pull-on

Measurements

• Sizes from 3 to 9.5

Benefits Horze Palermo Paddock Boots

• Waterproof
• Easy to clean
• Easy to put on and take off
• Sturdy

Drawbacks Horze Palermo Paddock Boots

• Not very warm
• Can make your feet sweat in summer

How it Compares to Others

The Horze Palemo paddock boots are shorter than many of the other options. Many will find them more comfortable to wear when doing daily barn chores and riding.

Expert Tips

Check out this video for tips on how to take care of rubber boots.

What Other Horse Parents Say About Horze Palermo Paddock Boots

These boots are popular for equestrians who want an everyday boot. Comments from users include ‘look great’, and ‘fit to size.”

Check Latest Price Horze Palermo Paddock Boots | Horze

#2 Ovation Derby – Men’s Lined Rubber Riding Boot – Men’s (WINNER)

Now that I’ve introduced you to my lady’s winner, let’s take a look at one of the best rubber rider boots for men. 

Finding men’s rubber riding boots is certainly more challenging with fewer options available. However, these boots are a great option. I particularly like that they are lined, something you don’t always get with rubber boots.

These boots have no seems, which ensures you stay nice and dry. They have a traditional, English tall riding boot look and are one of the most popular options for men. Dressage riders will like these stylish boots.

If you want to see non-rubber options as well, check out best riding boots brands.

Features & Attributes

• Moisture-wicking
• Lining
• Made from PVC
• English boots

Measurements

• Sizes 8 to 12

Benefits Ovation Derby – Men’s Lined Rubber Riding Boot

• Waterproof
• Internal lining
• Seamless

Drawbacks Ovation Derby – Men’s Lined Rubber Riding Boot

• No half sizes
• Can be hard to get on and off

How it Compares to Others

These are a tall boot for men that have a dressier style than some of the other options.

Expert Tips

While it’s not possible to get rubber riding boots that fit as well as leather, you still want to make sure they are as close to a good fit as possible. This video will give you some guidance on how to measure for tall boots.

What Other Horse Parents Say About Ovation Derby – Men’s Lined Rubber Riding Boot

Several users have remarked on the “excellent fit” and that the boots are “well made”. Some even use them for non-riding activities, like fancy dress costumes!

Women’s Rubber Riding Boots

My winner isn’t the only great option for women’s rubber riding boots, so let’s take a look at my other top picks.

#3 Horze Bonn Rubber Paddock Boots – Budget Friendly

HORZE Bonn rubber paddock boots are another short option. These are great for daily riding and barn work as they are comfortable and budget-friendly. 

Plus, they also offer a kid’s version. Perfect for kids who are tough on shoes and who are growing quickly. These are great for beginner riders.

Features & Attributes

• Elastic gussets
• Riding heel
• Anti-slip
• Ridged soles

Measurements

• Sizes from 6 to 10

Benefits Horze Bonn Rubber Paddock Boots

• Affordable price
• Waterproof
• Pull-on

Drawbacks Horze Bonn Rubber Paddock Boots

• Not warm for winter

How it Compares to Others

This pair of boots is a great price and cheaper than many other options. Plus, they aren’t just for women and come in children’s sizes.

Expert Tips

Rubber boots aren’t great for cold weather but there are some ways you can adjust them to help keep your feet warmer. Learn how in this video.

What Other Horse Parents Say About Horze Bonn Rubber Paddock Boots

HORZE is a really popular brand, those who have bought these boots agree! – “ love HORZE”.

Check Latest Price Horze Bonn Rubber Paddock Boots | Horze

#4 HORZE Chester Tall Dress Boots – Flexible

One downside of tall rubber boots is that they can be a bit stiff. However, these Chester boots from HORZE are made from a more flexible rubber, which helps make them more comfortable.

They are good value for money, so won’t break the bank. They have a great sole and heel height for horseback riding and are a cinch to keep clean.

You can purchase these boots on Amazon or Equinavia.

Features & Attributes

• Ribbed rubber soles
• Soft inner lining
• Supple rubber
• Similar to field boots

Measurements

• Sizes from 5.5 to 10.5

Benefits HORZE Chester Tall Dress Boots

• Durable sole
• Flexible rubber
• Comfortable lining
• Good value

Drawbacks HORZE Chester Tall Dress Boots

• Run small
• Not suitable for wide calves

How it Compares to Others

These are tall boots like many of the others but they are made with a more flexible rubber, which makes them more comfortable to ride in.

What Other Horse Parents Say About HORZE Chester Tall Dress Boots

Riders have some good things to say about these boots – “Sturdy and fantastic waterproof boots.”

#5 Muck Boots Derby Ankle Rubber Riding Boot – Most Comfortable

These shoes come from one of my favorite best riding boots brands, Muck Boots. Muck boots make a variety of durable boots for around the yard and have styles for cold weather.

This pair of boots is a little different from their usual models as they are designed for horse riding.

These are ankle boots in a paddock boot style and have some more features than many others, including extra comfort.

Features & Attributes

• EVA footbed
• Slip-resistant rubber outsole
• Steel shank
• 3mm neoprene bootie

Measurements

• Sizes from 3 to 9

Benefits Muck Boots Derby Ankle Rubber Riding Boot

• Breathable lining
• Warmer than most
• Neoprene lining

Drawbacks Muck Boots Derby Ankle Rubber Riding Boot

• A little expensive
• Some find them too narrow

How it Compares to Others

These rubber paddock boots have many more features than other options. They are warmer and have a more comfortable, supportive footbed.

Expert Tips

If you want to wear these boots in the winter with thick socks, it is a good idea to buy at least a size up from what you normally wear.

What Other Horse Parents Say About Muck Boots Derby Ankle Rubber Riding Boot

“Practical, versatile, quality, and comfort.” These are common remarks you’ll find about these boots.

Rubber Riding Boots Men’s 

Now, let’s see what else is available for male equestrians. Unfortunately, when it comes to rubber boots for male horse riders there is not much choice, so finding good ones is challenging.

#6 Totes Men’s Cirrus Chelsea Ankle Rain Boot – Best Short Boot

These ankle boots aren’t officially for horse riding. But I’m including them because they are a good short option for men.

My only word of caution is that the heel isn’t quite right for horse riding, so I don’t recommend beginners use them for riding. They are, however, fantastic for around the barn.

Features & Attributes

• Pull-on loops
• Slip-resistant
• Lining-free shell

Measurements

• Sizes 8 to 13

Benefits Totes Men’s Cirrus Chelsea Ankle Rain Boot 

• Lightweight
• Self heal punctures
• Waterproof

Drawbacks Totes Men’s Cirrus Chelsea Ankle Rain Boot 

• Not specifically for horse riding
• Tricky to get on

How it Compares to Others

These are similar to paddock boots but the sole and heel are not quite the same, as they aren’t designed for riders. However, they work great around the barn and for experienced riders.

Expert Tips

We all know how miserable your feet can feel in cold weather, especially in riding boots as they aren’t thick enough to provide enough warmth.

To help keep your feet warm, Spectrum Foot Clinics recommends “Warm thick woolen socks promote insulation for your feet. Two pairs of thin socks are more insulating than one pair of thick socks.” [1]

Also, used to use those little heat sachets in my boots in the winter and found them helpful.

What Other Horse Parents Say About Totes Men’s Cirrus Chelsea Ankle Rain Boot 

Users find these boots really lightweight, similar to Crocs, plus comfortable enough to wear for several hours.

Wide Calf Rubber Riding Boots

It is pretty hard to find rubber riding boots wide calf styles, unfortunately. But through my research, I did find a good pair that aren’t too expensive. Let’s take a look.

#7 Dublin Ladies Universal Tall Boots – Affordable

While not fancy, these wide calf rubber riding boots a versatile and don’t cost a fortune. They have an ideal sole for horse riding and a wide fit from the ankle right up to the top.

The brand states that these boots run small and suggest you buy one or two sizes up.

Features & Attributes

• Jersey lining
• Moisture-wicking
• Spur rests

Measurements

• Sizes 6 to 11
• Calf widths 15 ⅜ inches to 16 ¾ inches
• Height from 16 ⅜ inches to 17 ½ inches

Benefits Dublin Ladies Universal Tall Boots

• Fully waterproof
• Wide fit
• Great sole for riding

Drawbacks Dublin Ladies Universal Tall Boots

• Some find the foot tight
• Not a contour fit

How it Compares to Others

These boots are great for riders with wider calves, but others might find them too large.

Expert Tips

Working around the barn is tough on boots and at some point, rubber boots might leak. However, there is a fix that you can try instead of replacing them. Find out in this video.

What Other Horse Parents Say About Dublin Ladies Universal Tall Boots

Equestrians love the “bargain” price and find these boots perfect “around the barn”

How To Choose The Best Rubber Riding Boots?

Choosing the best rubber riding boots is pretty easy. This type of boot is fairly simple and most don’t come with fancy features.

If you want rubber because it will keep your feet dry, you can find alternative materials that are still waterproof. Check out waterproof horse riding boots to find a pair that suits.

Size

Rubber riding boot size can be a little tricky. These types of boots tend to be stiffer than leather and they don’t stretch to fit.

For maximum comfort consider going up a size. If you have wide calves finding a suitable challenge is often a challenge. A good alternative is to look at paddock boot styles.

Style

While there are hundreds of different types of rubber boots, it is important you look for a pair that is designed for horse riding.

These boots will have the correct type of sole and heel that you can put in a stirrup. Don’t buy a pair that is not horse rider-friendly as these boots have soles that are too thick, which is dangerous for your feet in the stirrups.

READ MORE: What Are Riding Boots Called?

FAQs

Final Recommendation

When it comes to the best rubber riding boots, the styles available are not as varied as leather options. However, these types of boots serve a purpose and do it well. 

The Horze Palermo Paddock Boots Women’s are great because they are short, which makes them more comfortable when riding. They will also suit more types of leg shapes than tall rubber boots.

Check Latest Price Horze Palermo Paddock Boots | Horze

Resources

1. How To Manage Cold Feet At Home [Internet]. Ireland’s Premier Chiropody & Podiatry Clinic Network. [cited 2022 Aug 4]. Available from: https://www.spectrumfootclinics.ie/blog/2021/1/29/how-to-manage-cold-feet-at-home