10 Best Saddle Pads for Horses: English & Western (2023)

Sharing is caring!

What are the top 10 best saddle pads for horses? 

I’ve saved you the struggle of digging through hundreds of different options by putting together this simple review guide.

Let’s get started, so you can get riding!

FYI, this post contains affiliate links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Don’t have time? Here is a quick comparison of our favorites!

10 Best Saddle Pads for Horses (Review Guide)

There are literally hundreds of different pads to choose from. That is certainly enough to give you a headache! But finding the best horse saddle pad doesn’t have to be hard. 

My saddle pads reviews below include some of my favorite options for both English and western riders.

#1 TuffRider Basic All Purpose Saddle Pad (WINNER)

For everyday schooling you need something that holds up to lots of use, fits your horse comfortably, isn’t too bulky, and doesn’t cost a lot.

TuffRider’s basic pad fits all of these requirements. It has a wither relief notch that allows a little extra room. I love how there are loads of fun colors to pick from and the price means you can buy a few.

Physical Attributes

• Diamond quilting
• Cotton & polyester fabric
• Billet straps
• Soft flannel underside

Quantitative Measurements

• One size
• 20-inches long along spine
• 21-inches from wither point to bottom edge
• 8-inch billet strap

Benefits	Drawbacks
Not expensive	The soft flannel underside can be very hard to clean horse hair off
Lots of color choice	Inconsistencies among different colors (some fabric is slicker than others)
Comfortable material
Not too fluffy
Budget option

How it Compares to Others and Why

This is one of the most budget-friendly English saddle pads you can find. It is too small to use with a western saddle. Also, it doesn’t have upper straps that loop around your girth straps.

Some people like these. Personally, I and many other experts don’t like them as they can create uncomfortable saddle pressure points.

Expert Tips

Use a stiff dandy brush to brush as much hair as possible off the pad before you put it in the wash.

#2 Dover Saddlery Quilted All-Purpose Piped Saddle Pad

Like the TuffRider, this is an all-purpose pad. It is a little fancier because it has piping, making some color combos suitable for the jumper ring.

Physical Attributes

• Light polyfill
• Diamond quilted
• Thin layer for foam
• Cotton fabric
• Girth loop

Quantitative Measurements

• 10 color choices
• One size

Benefits	Drawbacks
Durable design	Could use more wither room
Nice cushioning without bulk
Attractive

How it Compares to Others and Why

This equestrian pad is great for using with English saddles. It is more expensive than the cheapest options but for this, you get a fancier-looking pad.

Expert Tips

Before you attach your girth always put your hands under both ends of the pad at the top and pull it up into the gullet of your saddle. This will avoid putting lots of pressure across your horse’s spine.

#3 Tough 1 EquiRoyal Square

The Tough 1 EquiRoyal Square is a nice size pad that comes in a few color choices. It has white piping, which always makes saddle pads look fancier. You could get away with the black, green, or navy competing in showjumping.

Physical Attributes

• White piping
• Diamond pattern stitching
• Nylon billet and girth straps

Quantitative Measurements

• One size
• 8 colors

Benefits	Drawbacks
100% cotton	Some people find it too thin
Affordable price

How it Compares to Others and Why

This is an inexpensive pad that is great for schooling. It’s not nice enough for the show ring, like some of the others but good value for the price.

Expert Tips

Have more than one saddle pad so you can rotate them every couple of days or if one gets too wet or sweaty.

#4 Roma Circle Quilt Pad

Instead of the usual diamond shape quilt, this saddle pad uses a circle. It doesn’t really make much difference what pattern you use, but if you want something a little different consider this option.

This saddle pad is a school pad only. It comes in some really fun colors, but not colors suitable for the jumper ring. It has a nice thickness and comes in a smaller pony size as well as a full size.

Physical Attributes

• Circle quilting
• Nylon girth and billet straps
• White piping
• Different color trim options

Quantitative Measurements

• One size

Benefits	Drawbacks
Wick easy lining	Expensive for an everyday saddle pad
Soft and thick

How it Compares to Others and Why

This square saddle pad is a bit pricier than the other schooling pads on my list. However, it is a bit thicker, which some riders will prefer.

Expert Tips

Change your saddle pad every couple of days for a freshly washed one.

#5 Weatherbeeta Prime Jump Saddle Pad

A jumping saddle pad has a slightly different shape than regular schooling pads. The front is not straight down but cut with a curve at the front of the pad.

Instead of straps that attach to your billets, this saddle pad has a small strip of nylon the loops onto the D ring of your saddle. This places this strap higher on the pad and lessens the chance of uncomfortable pressure points.

Physical Attributes

• Mesh spine
• Wicking lining
• Cotton pad
• Girth patch

Quantitative Measurements

• 6 color choices
• Pony or full size

Benefits	Drawbacks
Durable	A little expensive
Trendy and modern looking
The girth patch lessens wear
High wither design

How it Compares to Others and Why

This saddle pad is more expensive than the other options. However, it incorporated some modern design features that not only help make the pad last longer it also aid the horse’s comfort level.

Expert Tips

Consider using the best half pads with this or any other pad to help absorb shock to your horse’s back.

#6 Success Equestrian Deluxe Hunter No Slip Saddle Pad

If you compete in the hunter or equitation, you will need a saddle-shaped pad in white. You can’t use jumping or square pads.

One thing that always frustrated me about these pads is that they would slip or bunch up under the saddle panels.

This pad is designed to overcome slipping with its grippy top and underside.

Physical Attributes

• Saddle shaped
• Sure grip top and bottom
• Shock absorption

Quantitative Measurements

• 50% percent cotton
• 30% polyester
• 20% PVC

Benefits	Drawbacks
Easy to wash	Suitable for shows only
Soft	Gets dirty quickly
Non-slip

How it Compares to Others and Why

This is a specially shaped saddle pad for the riders competing in equitation or hunter classes.

Expert Tips

It is possible to use a half-pad with this type of western saddle pad. You just need to choose carefully. It must be discreet and the same color. A good choice is Thinline.

#7 Weaver Leather Contoured Wool Blend Felt Saddle Pad

If you’re looking for a solid, best western saddle pad, this is a great choice! This saddle pad is made with wool which is one of the best natural materials to use on your horse.

It provides shock absorption, moisture-wicking ability, and pressure distribution.

Physical Attributes

• Wool blend felt
• Contoured design
• Top grain leather on high wear areas
• Beige in color
• Brown leather

Quantitative Measurements

• 30 x 30 inches
• One size

Benefits	Drawbacks
Reputable western brand	Not many color choices
Leather patches reduce wear	Some feel it’s rather stiff and hard
Comfortable making for a happy horse
Durable

How it Compares to Others and Why

This is a saddle pad for western saddles only. Because of this is it bigger and thicker than the English products on this list. It is also one of the more expensive products, but you get good quality for the price.

Expert Tips

For a smaller horse or a pony, Weaver makes this saddle pad in a smaller size.

#8 Impact Gel Contour Felt Saddle Pad

I love how this western saddle pad integrates modern features in a discreet way. You wouldn’t know that this pad has gel buy just looking at it quickly. 

This is a premium quality wool blend saddle pad that has a hidden gel impact base layer. It has strips of leather over areas that take the most wear.

It helps to distribute pressure evenly and the wool improves breathability.

Physical Attributes

• Gel lining
• Wool blend
• Leather strips

Quantitative Measurements

• 30-inches long
• 32-inches wide
• 1-inch thick

Benefits	Drawbacks
Made in the U.S.A	Expensive
Breathable and flexible	Only two colors
Evens out pressure
Non-slip

How it Compares to Others and Why

Compared to other western saddle pads this is an excellent option despite its hefty price tag. The gel combined with the wool makes it one of the best saddle pads available for use in western riding.

Expert Tips

If you feel 1-inch is too thick, this pad comes in a variety of thickness options with the thinnest being ½ inch.

#9 Quilted English All-Purpose Trail Saddle Pad

Taking your horse trail riding is a fun way to relax and strengthen the bond between you and your equine partner.

However, when out on the trail you should always bring a few items with you to ensure the welfare of your horse and yourself.

This is one of the best saddle pads for trail riding options. It is ideal for carrying those extra bits with you without taking up your hands.

This English trail riding pad has a great pocket where you can store your phone and a bottle of water. It is suitable for most trail levels.

Physical Attributes

• Diamond quilted
• 2 side pockets
• Girth and billets straps
• Pocket buckle closures
• White piping

Quantitative Measurements

• 23-inches long
• 22-inch drop
• Comes in black

Benefits	Drawbacks
Big enough to use with some western saddles	Only one color choice
Generous pocket size
Storage

How it Compares to Others and Why

Because this saddle pad has pockets it’s not really suitable for arena riding. It is a little expensive for a quilted saddle pad but not outrageous. If you want a school saddle pad consider one of the others on the list.

Expert Tips

If the pad doesn’t slip, which is should when everything fits correctly, and the billet straps don’t get used cut them off. This will help avoid creating unwanted pressure points.

#10 Reinsman Durable Square Contour Saddle Pad

This is another of my favorite western saddle pads. It is an ideal choice for casual riding or more intensive daily training. It also has two different underlayers that you can choose from.

The top layer is durable and designed to keep its color even with exposure to the sun and is stain resistant.

Physical Attributes

• Internal comfort felt
• Fleece or tacky bottom
• Comes in black, brown, or desert sky

Quantitative Measurements

• 32-inches long
• 32-inch drop
• ¾ inch thick

Benefits	Drawbacks
Absorbs shock	Might slip on lighter built horses
UV protection	Limited color options
Durable
Resists stains
Fits most horse comfortably

How it Compares to Others and Why

For a western saddle pad, this is a good price. It has UV and stain protection, which not many others have.

Expert Tips

While fleece is lovely and soft, I suggest using the version that has a tacky bottom. Fleece is very hard to clean properly and you will never get all the hairs out. This can shorten the pad’s life.

How to Choose the Best Saddle Pad for Trail Riding

While most saddle pads will do the job you want for trail riding, you should consider looking for one that is designed with this activity in mind.

Durability and Quality

Check: What Size Saddle Pad Do I Need?

Comfort

Traveling across varying and sometimes rough terrain can be tough on your horse. It is essential that a trailing riding saddle pad is comfortable for your horse.

A pad that has a good cushioning effect for the horse and rider is what you want to look out for. You also want a trailing riding pad that is breathable and has moisture-wicking qualities.

It is also important the saddle pad fits well and doesn’t slip. If it does slip it can cause pressure points which can make your horse very uncomfortable and even sore.

How to Choose the Best English Saddle Pad

Choosing the best English saddle pad will depend on a few different factors. First, what discipline do you ride? If you area dressage rider, you will need a pad cut in the right shape for this type of saddle.

How much activity you do with your horse will also affect the type of saddle pad you need. If you do intensive work use one the is good at pulling moisture away from the skin.

You also need to look at saddle pad sizes. The size must be suitable for your saddle. This means that it needs to be larger than the saddle so that pressure isn’t put on the edges pushing it into the horse. It also looks a lot tidier if it is the right size!

A breathable saddle pad is also non-negotiable. This is will help heat the builds up under the saddle escape.

Look for pads that are cut in a way to allow room for the withers and always pull the pad up into the saddle’s gullet. For high-withered horses, you will need the best saddle pad for high withered horses.

Check:

• Fitting Saddle for Swayback Horse
• Causes & Treatment of Roach Back in Horses
• How to Make a Saddle Pad?

Check out this video on how to use a gel pad under a saddle.

Also, don’t forget to check our guide on how to store saddle pads, as once you bought the saddle pads, you will need to take care of and this guide will help you a lot.

FAQs

Let’s take a look at some common and important questions the often come up about saddle pads.

Conclusion

Choosing a saddle pad is certainly overwhelming.

There is tons of choice! However, make a shortlist of must-have criteria and then narrow down your options. Then it just comes down to personal preference, such as choosing the color you want.

Final Recommendation

For English riders needing a pad for daily training sessions, TuffRider is one of the best choices.

It is cheap and comes in fun colors, as well as being comfortable for your horse. If you ride western then I really love the Impact Gel saddle pad.

What are your favorite saddle pads for horses? Let us know in the comments below!